Did a Plane Fall, or Did Our Trust Crash Too? Unmasking the Truth Behind the Ahmedabad AI171 Tragedy
Published on: July 15, 2025
By: PARTHASARATHI PANDA✈️ The Tragedy in Ahmedabad Skies
On the morning of June 12, 2025, an Air India flight — AI171, a Boeing 787 Dreamliner — crashed mere seconds after take-off from Ahmedabad. The plane barely reached 650 to 825 feet in altitude before both engines failed. Within 32 seconds, the plane plunged from the sky, claiming the lives of everyone onboard, including two veteran pilots — Captain Sumit Sabharwal, a pilot with over 30 years of experience, and First Officer Clive Kunder, a seasoned professional with thousands of flying hours.
But as tragic as the event was, the aftermath may be even more disturbing.
 |
| Did a Plane Fall, or Did Our Trust Crash Too? Unmasking the Truth Behind the Ahmedabad AI171 Tragedy - AI Image |
⚖️ The Blame Game: Are Pilots Being Scapegoated?
💬 A Narrative Quickly Formed
Within days, the preliminary investigation report blamed the pilots, citing that the fuel cut-off switches were turned off manually, causing both engines to fail. The tone was clear: human error. Case closed?
But is it ever that simple?
Pilot associations like ALPA India called the findings one-sided. Aviation experts are asking:
-
Can experienced pilots really make such a fundamental mistake?
-
Why were both fuel switches turned off just seconds apart?
-
If the pilots had made such a conscious error, why did they send a “MAYDAY” distress call in panic?
One of the last cockpit recordings reveals a chilling moment:
Pilot 1: "Why did you turn off the switch?"
Pilot 2: "I didn't do anything."
This exchange, filled with confusion and alarm, suggests the situation was far from intentional. It points to something much deeper — a potential technical failure.
🛠️ Was It a Design Flaw? Boeing’s Dark History Resurfaces
⚠️ Known Warnings Ignored?
Back in 2018, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) had already warned Boeing about design issues related to fuel switch systems in the 787 model. But was any corrective action taken?
This wouldn't be the first time Boeing ignored warnings — and paid in human lives later.
🕵️ History Repeats?
In 2018 and 2019, two Boeing 737 MAX crashes killed 346 people. The cause?
A software malfunction (MCAS) Boeing knew about, but didn't properly disclose or train pilots for.
Initially, Boeing and others blamed the pilots.
Only after public outcry and deeper investigations was Boeing forced to admit its fault.
Now ask yourself: Is the same script playing out again with AI171?
 |
| Did a Plane Fall, or Did Our Trust Crash Too? Unmasking the Truth Behind the Ahmedabad AI171 Tragedy - AI Image |
🔍 Red Flags in the Ahmedabad Case
🚨 Dual Fuel Switch Failure
Turning off both engine fuel switches is not an easy, accidental move — especially by trained pilots. That both switches went off within seconds points towards a possible systematic malfunction, or even a cascading electrical or software failure.
🛰️ Why Didn’t the ELT Work?
The Emergency Locator Transmitter (ELT) — which sends signals in case of a crash — failed too.
Was that pilot error too?
Unlikely.
ELT malfunction suggests maintenance oversight or design flaws, neither of which are the pilot's responsibility.
📄 Lopsided Report?
The 15-page preliminary report makes minimal mention of technical faults, and focuses almost entirely on pilot actions. It barely touches on Boeing or General Electric's roles, even though both are deeply involved in the aircraft’s design and engine systems.
🧑✈️ The Silence of the Dead: Who Will Speak for the Pilots?
Both pilots are dead. They cannot defend themselves.
This makes the integrity of the investigation even more important.
If they are being blamed without full evidence, this isn’t just an insult to their legacy — it’s a dangerous precedent.
A cover-up now means another disaster later.
 |
| Did a Plane Fall, or Did Our Trust Crash Too? Unmasking the Truth Behind the Ahmedabad AI171 Tragedy - AI Image |
🏢 Boeing: A Pattern of Denial and Delay
Boeing’s track record shows a pattern:
| Year | Incident | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | Lion Air 610 crash | 189 dead – blamed on software issue (MCAS) |
| 2019 | Ethiopian Airlines crash | 157 dead – same MCAS failure |
| 2024 | South Korea (737-800) | 180 dead – suspected design flaw |
| 2025 | US cockpit seat failure | 50 injured – technical fault |
In all cases, Boeing:
-
Delayed response
-
Deflected blame
-
Often blamed pilot error initially
So when AI171’s early report focuses solely on pilot blame — you have to ask:
Is this another Boeing deflection?
🚫 A Culture of Silence, or Systemic Failure?
The truth is: India’s aviation oversight bodies, Air India management, and global regulatory agencies like FAA are also under scrutiny.
-
Were prior alerts ignored?
-
Was maintenance compromised?
-
Why wasn't the ELT functional?
-
Why are critical technical questions missing from the report?
These unanswered questions create the perfect conditions for injustice — not just for the victims, but for the public trust in air safety.
🧭 What Needs to Be Done?
✅ Transparent and Independent Investigation
An impartial investigation must:
-
Re-evaluate fuel switch failure possibilities
-
Test the ELT functionality and maintenance logs
-
Review the aircraft’s flight data history
-
Include independent international aviation experts
✅ Accountability for All Parties
Not just the pilots. But:
-
Boeing
-
Air India Maintenance
-
Regulatory Authorities
All should be open to scrutiny.
🛑 Conclusion: Don’t Let the Truth Crash Too
The crash of AI171 wasn’t just a plane crash — it was a crash of public trust.
If pilots with decades of experience are made scapegoats, while large corporations and regulators walk away clean, then every passenger’s safety is at risk.
Until there’s real accountability — not just for human error, but for design flaws, corporate negligence, and systemic apathy — these tragedies will repeat.
Let’s not wait for the next flight to prove that.
📝 What Do You Think?
Was the AI171 crash a case of pilot error, or a larger cover-up?
Let me know in the comments.
Don’t forget to share this article and raise awareness.
🔗 Sources:
FAA Safety Bulletins, 2018
Preliminary AI171 Report, June 2025
Boeing Safety Records (2018–2025)
ALPA India Press Release, July 2025
Eyewitness and cockpit audio (via official investigation brief)
